Part I
-
For the first part of the assignment I found
this a little difficult. One of the hardest parts was getting my points or
opinions across on subjects, things such as explaining getting a puppy, or
having to get my car washed, this felt like trying to communicate with someone
who spoke a different language so I tried to get my points across by doing
motions that would be easily figured out, such as putting both hands in front
of me as if I was driving a car. As we got further into the conversation, my
partner had to really pay attention to my movements and ask a little bit more
questions that were yes and no as I made my gestures. As my partner did change
to better understand the way I talked I also realized unconsciously she slowled
down the way she spoke as if she was speaking to someone who barely understood
her questions like an individual who is maybe not familiar with English. If me
and my partner were two different cultures meeting for the first time, due to
the fact she has more ways of communicating, she had a bigger advantage in the
language/culture barriers. It is really hard for me to fully express myself
lacking ability to use symbolic language, so I do think in some way someone
with more expressions and ways of explaining their points or views will have
the advantage. The speaking culture might get frustrated after some time due to
the fact they have to concentrate harder to get the other cultures point
across. One of the cultures that has trouble communicating in a similar way to
this exercise would be first generation Hispanic individuals due to the fact a
lot of them do not understand English too well. Some of the reason that they
have a disadvantage as well is that there are very different parts of the
English language with a lot of words that sound the same. This affects how they
interact everyday with friends, or co-workers in a big way so they have to
become very body language expressive. IF there was anything that could make it
easier for them to communicate is to better look at facial expression as well
as gestures of the other conversation partner.
Part II
-
To be fully honest this part of the assignment
was very easy for me, to keep a monotone voice and no hand gestures. My brother
has been doing something similar for a while where he changes accents such as
Irish or imitates different people. So after observing him do that random I
thought I would give this a good shot at a place with a lot of random people.
So to do this part of the assignment I did it at a St. Patrick’s Day party. Most
people that saw the way I was acting at first a little weird, and as I
continued the assignment I realized a lot of people would notice me say
something to maybe a joke with no change in a tone of voice so they didn’t know
whether I was being sarcastic or truthful with my statements. The difficulties
of this other than not being able to see if someone is joking or being serious
was that there was no follow through with certain words when explaining a story
such as a car accident that I happen to drive by, without those expressions it
was just clear that people had a hard time in a bit of a way following along to
what I said. I can see groups of people that have no social skills or maybe
that were home schooled to have issues with things such as body language due to
only experiencing it from a few group of people but none to the extreme of the
exercise, I can also see people with language barriers having issues with body
language due to each “culture” expressing differently though achieving the same
result. One of the adaptive benefits to reading
body language would be that you can get a point across or lead a
conversation with such things, the more visuals you can bring to somebody in a
conversation the easier it is to follow along which allows from a better
relation within those boundaries. It is really hard to see it sometimes because
we get very interested in products but when shopping for things such as cars or
maybe cell phones, we like ask questions which we might know the answer to, but
in the way sales people will get you fascinated and keep you interested is by
working a lot with their body movements and reading yours. Sales people guide
you to where you feel most comfortable within a conversation, so I do believe
that not showing body language or exercising in those point would be best fit
for when going around and shopping for certain things. One of the other things
about this is that if you chose to ignore a salesperson’s body language, there
si a big change what they are trying to excite you about will not leave you
surprised or wanting exactly what they are inending to sell you. So in a real
life situation there is benefits to no body language as well as monotone
speech.
Well done. I especially like how you described the benefit to limiting body language and voice emotion in a sales situation. But would there ever be a situation where it would be an advantage to you to not be able to read body language? I can see the advantage to withholding body language to not give the other person clues to what you are thinking, but what about the other way around?
ReplyDeleteHi Marissela,
ReplyDeleteThis was a very good post. It is really interesting to me that when we play charades, we think its fun. Yet, when doing this experiment and we had to do it, we became more frustrated. Speaking to most humans is really easy. We learn how to talk at a young age and we continue using it throughout our life. When we had to stop speaking and using had gestures, we took away part of ourselves. This experiment was really hard for me. The way you described driving a car was very creative. This experiment certainly taught me not to take language for granted.
Hey Marissela,
ReplyDeleteYou wrote a very clear and elegant post, very nice. The same thing happened with my friend during the experiment. As our conversation developed his way of speaking became more and more primitive. Soon enough we were jumping around making loud noises at each other. I'm glad the mono tone part of the experiment was easier for you. It was actually harder for me. I speak with a lot of character and emotion, which made this part very difficult. After failing my friend tried it out and completed it no problem. You guys can be robot friends together... Great post!
-Tyler